top of page
  • Grey Instagram Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon

When I Survey the Wondrous Cross: Poetry That Teaches Us What Really Matters

Sep 29
6 min read
Love that demands my all.
Love that demands my all.

There are hymns that invite us to sing.

There are hymns that invite us to worship.

And then there are hymns that invite us to stop—to look, to think, and to see our lives differently.

Isaac Watts's “When I Survey the Wondrous Cross” is one of those hymns.


Watts did not begin with himself. He began with the Cross:

“When I survey the wondrous crossOn which the Prince of glory died…”

The word survey is important.

He is not glancing at the Cross.

He is not passing by it.

He is looking carefully at it.

And as he looks, everything else begins to change.


Isaac Watts and a New Kind of Hymn


Isaac Watts (1674–1748) is often called the father of English hymnody. He wrote more than 600 hymns, but “When I Survey the Wondrous Cross” is widely regarded as one of his greatest.


The hymn first appeared in Hymns and Spiritual Songs in 1707 and was included in the enlarged 1709 edition. Watts originally intended it as a hymn for the Lord's Supper. Its subtitle was “Crucifixion to the World, by the Cross of Christ,” drawn from Galatians 6:14:

“But God forbid that I should glory, save in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom the world is crucified unto me, and I unto the world.”

That verse gives us the key to understanding the hymn.

Watts is not merely describing the Cross.

He is describing what happens to a person who truly looks at it.


“My Richest Gain I Count but Loss”

The first stanza moves immediately from the Cross to the heart:

“My richest gain I count but loss,And pour contempt on all my pride.”

That is a remarkable statement.

Watts does not say that everything in life is worthless. He says that everything must be revalued when compared with Christ crucified.


Paul had written something very similar:

“What things were gain to me, those I counted loss for Christ.”—Philippians 3:7

The Cross changes our accounting system.

What once seemed enormously important can suddenly look small.

  • Recognition.

  • Possessions.

  • Achievements.

  • Reputation.

  • Pride.

Even the things we are most tempted to boast about become insignificant beside what Christ accomplished at Calvary.


The hymn does not ask us to admire the Cross from a safe distance.

It asks us to let the Cross examine us.


“Forbid It, Lord, That I Should Boast”


The second stanza takes Watts directly to Galatians 6:14:

“Forbid it, Lord, that I should boast,Save in the death of Christ, my God…”

Notice the words “Christ, my God.”

Watts is not writing about a mere martyr.

He is not writing about a great moral teacher who died tragically.

  • The One hanging upon the Cross is the Prince of Glory.

  • He is Christ.

  • He is God.

  • And He died.

That is the wonder at the center of the hymn.


The Cross is not merely an example of sacrificial love. It is the place where the Son of God gave Himself for sinners.


And therefore Watts continues:

“All the vain things that charm me most,/I sacrifice them to his blood.”

That is where the hymn becomes personal.

What are the “vain things” that charm us?

Watts leaves the answer with us.


He does not provide a list.

He knows that the things which tempt one person may not tempt another. But whatever competes with Christ for our hearts must eventually be brought to the Cross.


“Sorrow and Love Flow Mingled Down”


Then comes the stanza that may be the most memorable of all:

“See, from his head, his hands, his feet,Sorrow and love flow mingled down…”

There is extraordinary poetry in those words.

  • Sorrow and love.

  • The Cross contains both.

  • There is the terrible sorrow of crucifixion.

  • There is the astonishing love of the One who willingly endured it.

And Watts asks:

“Did e'er such love and sorrow meet,Or thorns compose so rich a crown?”

The crown of thorns was intended as mockery.

Watts sees something more.


The soldiers meant it as humiliation.

Watts sees a crown.


The world looked at Jesus and saw a defeated man.

  • Faith looks at Jesus and sees the Prince of Glory.

  • That is what the Cross does to our vision.

  • It teaches us to see what the world cannot see.


The Verse Watts Removed


There is a fascinating part of the hymn's history that is easily missed.

Watts's original hymn contained five stanzas. One of them was later omitted:

“His dying crimson, like a robe,Spreads o'er his body on the tree;Then am I dead to all the globe,And all the globe is dead to me.”

I find that verse especially interesting because it explains the hymn's original subtitle: “Crucifixion to the World, by the Cross of Christ.”


The Cross does not merely tell us that Christ died.

It calls us to die to the world's claim upon us.


Paul put it this way:

“By whom the world is crucified unto me, and I unto the world.”—Galatians 6:14

That is deeper than admiring the Cross.

  • It is deeper even than being moved by the Cross.

  • It is allowing the Cross to change what we love, what we pursue, and what we consider important.


“Were the Whole Realm of Nature Mine”


And then Watts reaches the climax:

“Were the whole realm of nature mine,That were a present far too small;Love so amazing, so divine,Demands my soul, my life, my all.”


What could we possibly give in return?

Everything we possess?

Not enough.


The whole realm of nature?

Still not enough.


  • Our money?

  • Our accomplishments?

  • Our reputation?

  • Our service?

  • None of these can repay what Christ has done.

And yet Watts does not conclude by saying that nothing matters.

He concludes with the opposite.

Everything matters because Christ has given everything.

Therefore:

“Demands my soul, my life, my all.”

The Cross does not merely ask for a Sunday morning response.

It asks for the whole life.


The Poetry Becomes Prayer


That is what makes this hymn so powerful.

It begins with seeing:

“When I survey…”

Then comes revaluation:

“My richest gain I count but loss…”

Then repentance:

“I sacrifice them to his blood…”

Then wonder:

“Did e'er such love and sorrow meet?”

And finally surrender:

“Demands my soul, my life, my all.”

There is a spiritual journey contained in four short stanzas.

  • Look at the Cross.

  • See Christ.

  • Understand what He has done.

  • And then give yourself to Him.


What Happens When We Survey the Cross?


Perhaps that is the question Watts wants us to ask.

What happens when we really look at Calvary?

  • Our pride becomes smaller.

  • Our accomplishments become less important.

  • Our possessions lose some of their power over us.

  • Our love for Christ grows larger.

  • And our understanding of what it means to follow Him becomes clearer.

The Cross does not merely tell us what Jesus did then.

It tells us how we are to live now.

That is why this old hymn still speaks so powerfully after more than three centuries.


Last week, in “Be Thou My Vision,” we considered a hymn that asks Christ to become the One through whom we see everything else.

Now Isaac Watts takes us to the Cross and shows us what happens when we actually look.

  • We see our pride differently.

  • We see our possessions differently.

  • We see our ambitions differently.

  • We see our lives differently.

  • And, most importantly, we see Christ.

When we truly survey the wondrous Cross, we discover that the greatest treasure is not what we have gained.

It is the One who gave Himself for us.


And so Watts leaves us with a prayer that is difficult to improve upon:

“Love so amazing, so divine,Demands my soul, my life, my all.”

************************

The cross it standeth fast,

Hallelujah! hallelujah!

Defying every blast,

Hallelujah! hallelujah!

The winds of hell have blown,

The world its hate hath shown,

Yet it is not overthrown,

Hallelujah for the cross!

Hallelujah, hallelujah,

Hallelujah for the cross;

Hallelujah, hallelujah,

It shall never suffer loss.

2

It is the old cross still,

Hallelujah! hallelujah!

Its triumph let us tell,

Hallelujah! hallelujah!

The grace of God here shone,

Through Christ the blessed Son,

Who hath redemption won,

Hallelujah for the cross!

3

’Twas here the debt was paid,

Hallelujah! hallelujah!

Our sins on Jesus laid,

Hallelujah! hallelujah!

So round the cross we sing

Of Christ, our offering,

Of Christ, our living King,

Hallelujah for the cross!


Lyrics:Horatius Bonar (1808-1889)


 
 
 

Comments


SIGN UP FOR ALL UPDATES, POSTS & NEWS

Thanks for submitting!

  • Grey Instagram Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon
bottom of page